How Often Do Car Accident Cases Go to Court?

Most car accident cases settle without ever going to court. However, not all disputes are that easy. When fault is disputed, injuries are severe or insurance companies won’t offer fair compensation, a trial may be the only option. Knowing how often these cases go to court and what factors decide that can help you prepare for what’s ahead.

In this blog, we’ll look at how often car accident cases go to court, what drives cases to trial, why most cases settle, and how working with an Atlanta car accident lawyer can make all the difference in getting you the best result.

Why Most Car Accident Cases Settle

Every case is different but most car accident cases settle because of several practical reasons that make settling more attractive.

Cost and Time

Trials come with big financial and time costs. Both sides have to pay legal fees, court costs, and in many cases expert witnesses to support their side. Lawyers have to spend a lot of time preparing, discovering, and court appearances. Trials can drag on for months or even years adding uncertainty to the timeline. For these reasons, parties often settle early to save time and avoid mounting expenses.

Risk of Unpredictable Outcomes

In court, the outcome of a trial is always uncertain. In a car accident trial, judges or juries make decisions based on the evidence and arguments presented but their interpretation may be different from what either side expects. There is always the risk of an unfavorable verdict. Settlements offer more control over the outcome by allowing both sides to agree on terms that mitigate the risk of going to trial.

Preference for Privacy

Court proceedings are public so personal, financial, or sensitive information disclosed during the trial becomes part of the public record. Many individuals and businesses prefer to avoid that. Settlements often include confidentiality clauses so the terms of the agreement and the case remain private. This level of discretion is especially important for companies that want to protect their reputation or individuals who want to avoid public scrutiny.

Insurance Company Tactics

Insurance companies have a big say in whether car accident cases go to court. They often want to settle to avoid the costs and risks of trial. Settling early allows them to manage cases efficiently and reduce the chance of being hit with bigger payouts in court. Insurers use experienced negotiators and established processes to finalize agreements so settling is the preferred option for all parties.

What Drives Car Accident Cases to Trial?

While settlements are the most common outcome, certain situations push car accident cases to trial. When negotiations break down or parties can’t agree on the key issues a trial becomes necessary to settle the dispute fairly and completely.

Disputed Fault

Determining who was at fault is key to resolving cases but in some cases, the parties strongly disagree on liability. Conflicting accounts or evidence leaves no room for compromise. When both sides are convinced they are right a trial allows for a deeper dive into the facts including witness testimony, accident reconstruction, and expert opinions to help a judge or jury make a final decision.

Low Settlement Offers

Insurance companies may offer settlements that don’t cover the injured party’s losses such as medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. If the offer is too low and further negotiations don’t produce a fair result the plaintiff may decide to take the case to trial. In court, they can present detailed evidence of their damages and argue for compensation that reflects the full extent of their losses, often leading to a car accident lawsuit to resolve complex liability issues and establish legal precedents.

Complex Legal or Factual Issues

Some cases involve complex legal standards or factual scenarios that make settling difficult. These might include multiple parties, disputes over insurance coverage, or complex injury cases. In these situations, the structured process of a trial allows for a detailed examination by a judge or jury so that all legal and factual issues are properly addressed.

High-Value Claims

When a case involves car accident victims with serious injuries or significant property damage, both sides may be less willing to compromise. Insurance companies will resist large payouts and plaintiffs have more to gain by pursuing the full value of their case. In these situations, the prospect of a trial becomes more likely as both sides weigh the potential reward against the risk of litigation.

Judge and Gavel - Car Accident Case

Court Process for Car Accident Cases

If a car accident case goes to court, it follows a structured process to ensure fairness and thoroughness. Knowing what to expect helps plaintiffs and defendants prepare.

Filing a Lawsuit

The court process starts with the plaintiff filing a complaint that outlines the accident details, the damages, and the legal grounds for the defendant’s liability. Once filed the defendant gets a summons and must respond, either admitting or denying the allegations. This first step initiates the case and allows both sides to start the formal legal process.

Discovery Phase

The discovery phase allows both sides to get evidence and assess the case. Attorneys exchange documents, submit written questions (interrogatories), and depose witnesses under oath. This process ensures transparency so there are no surprises at trial and provides the framework for the legal arguments. Strong preparation during discovery often determines whether the case will settle or go to trial.

Trial Phase

If the case doesn’t settle the case goes to trial. Both sides present their arguments to a judge or jury, starting with opening statements. The plaintiff, often a car accident victim, presents evidence and witness testimony to support their case, and then the defendant’s side cross-examines. Once the plaintiff rests the defendant presents their evidence and witnesses. After closing arguments, the judge or jury deliberates and delivers a verdict based on the evidence and the law.

Judgment and Appeals

After the trial, the judge enters a formal judgment based on the verdict. If the losing side believes the trial was conducted unfairly they can appeal. The appeals process reviews whether the trial was done properly not the facts. An appeals court can affirm, reverse, or modify the lower court’s decision and in some cases order a new trial.

Considerations For Plaintiffs and Defendants

When deciding to settle or go to trial both plaintiffs and defendants must consider several factors that can affect the outcome. Knowing these factors helps both sides make informed decisions throughout the process.

Degree of Injuries and Damages

The extent of the plaintiff’s injuries determines the direction of the case. Serious injuries such as long-term disability result in higher cases due to higher medical expenses, lost income, and ongoing care needs. The more damages the more potential compensation and the more the insurance companies will contest the case so if negotiations fail trial becomes a more viable option.

Availability of Evidence

The quality and amount of evidence available determines the direction of the car accident case. Clear evidence such as police reports, video footage, and eyewitness testimony makes a plaintiff’s case stronger and encourages the defendant to settle. Ambiguous or conflicting evidence creates uncertainty and may push both sides to trial where a judge or jury can weigh the facts.

Damage Calculation Disparities

Negotiations can break down when the parties can’t agree on the value of the case. Plaintiffs want compensation for medical bills, property damage, lost wages, and pain and suffering while defendants want to minimize the payout. Large differences in these calculations can make settlement unlikely especially if the plaintiff’s attorney believes a trial will result in a better outcome.

Jurisdictional Differences

The legal climate where the car accident case is filed also matters. Some states are more plaintiff-friendly while others have damage caps or encourage alternative dispute resolution. Statutes of limitations, evidence rules, and regional court tendencies can determine if a case will settle or go to trial.

Consult With an Experienced Atlanta Car Accident Attorney ASAP!

If you are unsure whether to pursue a settlement or take your car accident case to court, it is crucial to consult with an experienced car accident lawyer. Our team at GMV Law Group is here to help. We’ll evaluate your case, guide you through the legal process, and fight to secure the compensation you deserve.

Contact us at 404-975-4878 for a free case review today!

Read More Related Articles

Calling Insurance After Car Accident
Blog

How to Negotiate a Car Accident Settlement

Dealing with a car accident settlement can be a big hassle when you’re trying to get better and deal with medical bills and insurance claims. While you can try to

Bus Accident With Car
Blog

What is the Average Settlement For Bus Accident?

Bus accidents can result in serious injuries, emotional trauma, and financial burdens for victims. Whether you’re dealing with medical bills, lost wages, or long-term care needs, understanding bus accident compensation

Don't Hesitate! Our Goal is to Help You Get Maximum Compensation!

Were you or a loved one Injured in an accident? Don't wait, contact us right away!

GMV Law Group, LLP is here to help you get the compensation you deserve!